Artisan Sourdough Breads

Savory Artisan Loaves

Classic Sourdough
Our signature loaf. Crusty, chewy, and delightfully tangy. Who knew flour, water & salt could be so good?

Garlic & Chive
Savory and aromatic with roasted garlic, olive oil, and flecks of fresh chives.

Everything (but the bagel)
Packed with your favorite bagel flavor and full of poppyseeds, black and white sesame seeds, and plenty of dried garlic & onion… no bagel required.

French Onion
Rich caramelized onions and fresh thyme baked into golden perfection.

Sourcream & Onion
A tangy twist on a classic chip flavor: herby, tangy, addictive. Loaded with green onions and chives.

Cheddar Jalapeño
Sharp cheddar meets mellow heat for the ultimate savory kick. Mild to Moderate heat. A customer top-pick!

Rosemary Black Pepper
Earthy, herby, and perfectly peppery with every bite. Mild heat.

Italian Herb
A fragrant blend of basil, oregano, rosemary and thyme. The perfect loaf for literally any occasion.

Holiday Herb & Parmesan
Festive and full of cozy holiday herbs, topped with crispy fresh parmesan. Great to pair with any cozy meal.

Tomato Basil
Bright and summery with olive oil, slightly tart sun-dried tomato, and sweet homegrown basil.

Black Pepper & Turmeric
Warm and peppery with ribbons of golden turmeric throughout.

Rosemary Olive Oil
Soft, herb-kissed crumb with a drizzle of richness.

Hot Honey Cheddar
Sweet heat and melty cheese. This loaf is bold, balanced, and simply perfect.

Roasted Street Corn
Cornbread vibes with roasted corn, lime, chili, and Cotija-style flair.

Ingredients: organic, unbleached, unenriched, never bromated all-purpose flour, filtered water, sourdough starter (flour & water) and sea salt.

BULK DISCOUNTS AVAILABLE FOR LARGE ORDERS.

Sweet Artisan Loaves

Chocolate Vanilla Swirl
A decadent marbled loaf with the best of both worlds. Full of dutch-processed cocoa powder, vanilla bean, and chocolate chips.

Lemon Blueberry
Bright lemon and juicy blueberries in a soft, tangy crumb. A customer top-pick!

Double Chocolate Espresso
Deep cocoa meets bold espresso for a mocha-lover’s dream.

Cinnamon Swirl
Sweet cinnamon ribbons baked into pillowy sourdough goodness. Baker’s favorite!

Cranberry Walnut
Tart cranberries and toasty walnuts… perfectly balanced and cozy.

White Chocolate Cherry Almond
A dreamy trio of creamy, tart, and nutty flavors in every slice.

Pumpkin Spice
Warm fall spices and pumpkin purée in a soft, seasonal loaf. Available year-round, because duh.

Chocolate Strawberry
Sweet strawberries and rich chocolate in a soft, decadent crumb.

White Chocolate Raspberry
A sweet, soft sourdough studded with raspberries and creamy white chocolate chunks.

Red Velvet
A cocoa-kissed, ruby loaf with cream cheese chips… classic red velvet vibes.

Chocolate Pistachio
Dark chocolate and nutty pistachios in a rich, elegant loaf swirled with pistachio cream.

Triple Berry
Blackberries, blueberries, and raspberries, the perfect summer bread available year-round.

Hot Cocoa
Like a mug of cocoa in bread form! Chocolatey, soft, and comforting with a mild milk chocolate dough and bits of marshmallow throughout.

Cinnamon Chip
Sweet cinnamon chips melted into a tender classic sourdough loaf. An artisan twist on the childhood “cinnamon sugar toast” in my eyes!

PB & J
Peanut butter and berries baked into a nostalgic, cozy bite. Kids top-pick!

Ingredients: organic, unbleached, unenriched, never bromated all-purpose flour, filtered water, sourdough starter (flour & water) and sea salt.

BULK DISCOUNTS AVAILABLE FOR LARGE ORDERS.

Sourdough Bakes

Sourdough Bagels ✦ $30/dozen (24+ $27/dozen)
Long-fermented and hand-shaped, these bagels are chewy, golden, and SO flavorful.
Available in Plain, Salt, Sesame, Poppyseed, Everything, Parmesan, Onion, Cheddar Jalapeno, Blueberry, and Cinnamon.
Ingredients: organic, unbleached, unenriched, never bromated all-purpose flour, filtered water, sourdough starter (flour & water) dry whole milk powder, olive oil, granulated sugar, and sea salt.

XL Sourdough English Muffins ✦ $24/dozen (24+ $22/dozen)
Extra-large and fluffy with a soft interior and crisp griddled edges. Perfect for breakfast sandwiches, brunch spreads, or slathering with butter and jam.
Available in Plain, Cheddar & Chive, and Cinnamon Raisin
Ingredients: organic, unbleached, unenriched, never bromated all-purpose flour, whole milk, sourdough starter (flour & water) egg, local honey, and sea salt.

Sourdough Dinner Rolls ✦ $22/dozen (24+ $20/dozen)
Soft, buttery, and topped with flakes of sea salt. These rolls are pillowy and rich with sourdough flavor… perfect for dinner tables or sliders.
Available with or without flakey sea salt and/or rosemary.
Ingredients: organic, unbleached, unenriched, never bromated all-purpose flour, whole milk, sourdough starter (flour & water) egg, salted butter, local honey, and sea salt.

10x7 Foccacia Slabs ✦ $14/each
Golden & airy, these sourdough focaccia slabs are topped with seasonal veggies, herbs, and flake salt. A stunning centerpiece for grazing tables, charcuterie spreads, or family-style meals.
Available in: Sea Salt & Rosemary, Potato & Onion, Sundried Tomato Basil, Garden Veggie, Cinnamon Bun, Blueberry, Triple Berry
Ingredients: organic, unbleached, unenriched, never bromated all-purpose flour, filtered water, sourdough starter (flour & water) olive oil, and sea salt.

Sourdough Pizza Crusts ✦ $30/4 Count 10-inch ✦ $45/4 Count 14-inch
Artisan crusts made with long-fermented dough and hand-shaped for a rustic feel. Crispy, chewy, and packed with tangy sourdough flavor, just add your favorite sauce and toppings! Perfect for pizza parties.
Ingredients: organic, unbleached, unenriched, never bromated all-purpose flour, filtered water, sourdough starter (flour & water) olive oil, and sea salt.

BULK DISCOUNTS AVAILABLE FOR LARGE ORDERS.

Sourdough Sweet Treats

Sourdough Chocolate Chip Cookies ✦ 12/$36 or 24/$50
Big, bold, & buttery. These ¼lb bakery-style cookies are long-fermented and perfectly balanced with rich chocolate, crispy edges, and soft, chewy centers.
Ingredients: organic unbleached all purpose flour, salted butter, brown sugar, granulated sugar, sourdough starter, (organic unbleached flour, filtered water) chocolate chips (sugar, chocolate liquor, cocoa butter, butterfat (milk), soy lecithin, and vanilla extract) egg, vanilla bean paste, sea salt.

Sourdough Cinnamon Rolls ✦ $22/7-inch Round Pan (About 6 Cinnamon Rolls)
Soft and swirled with cinnamon-sugar, then topped with your choice of dreamy glaze or creamy cheesecake flavored American Buttercream. Available baked/packaged individually or beautifully packaged in round pans for sharing.
Ingredients: organic all purpose unbleached/unenriched flour, sourdough starter, (unbleached flour, filtered water) whole milk, salted butter, brown sugar, egg, vanilla bean paste, organic cinnamon, sea salt. Buttercream: organic salted butter, powdered sugar, vanilla bean paste, lemon juice, cheesecake flavor (propylene glycol, water, natural flavors) sea salt. Glaze: whole milk, confectioner’s sugar, lemon juice, sea salt.

Sourdough Scones ✦ $36/Dozen
Tender, flaky, and full of bold flavor. These sourdough scones are just sweet enough and perfect for breakfast spreads, brunch buffets, or afternoon tea.
Available in Vanilla Bean, Blueberry Lemon, Lemon Twist, Orange Cream, Chocolate Chip, Cinnamon Bun, and Strawberry Cheesecake
Ingredients: organic all purpose unbleached/unenriched flour, sourdough starter (flour and water), whole milk, butter, granulated sugar, egg, and sea salt.

Sourdough Bomboloni Donuts ✦ $60/Dozen
Light and pillowy sourdough donuts filled with fresh raspberry jam or Nutella. A fun and elegant treat for any celebration or dessert bar.
Filled with your choice of fresh raspberry jam or Nutella.
Ingredients: organic unbleached bread flour, whole milk, sourdough starter (flour & water), butter, egg, granulated sugar, salt.

Sourdough Brown Butter Brownies ✦ Sizes & Pricing Coming Soon
Rich and fudgy with deep caramelized flavor from brown butter. Topped with a thin layer of indulgent chocolate ganache and signature gold dust.
Available plain or topped with nostalgic dye-free cosmic sprinkles.
Ingredients: organic unbleached bread flour, egg, brown sugar, salted butter, vanilla bean paste, dutch-processed cocoa powder, chocolate (sugar, chocolate liquor, cocoa butter, milkfat, and soy lecithin) and sea salt.

Sourdough Banana Bread ✦ Sizes & Pricing Coming Soon
Moist, naturally sweet, and full of ripe banana flavor. This long-fermented loaf is a cozy classic with a sourdough twist.
Ingredients: organic bananas, unbleached flour, brown sugar, avocado oil, sourdough starter (flour and water), milk, egg, pure vanilla extract, baking soda, sea salt.

BULK DISCOUNTS AVAILABLE FOR LARGE ORDERS.

Coming Soon: Sourdough Croissants, Sourdough Cardamom Buns, Sourdough Danish

How It Works

1. Browse the Menu: Choose your items and quantities. Have something custom in mind? Let’s chat!

2. Fill Out the Catering Form: Click here!

3. Pickup or Local Delivery: We’ll coordinate a pickup time from our home-based bakery in Lancaster, OH. Delivery may be an option if needed.

Please Note

We kindly ask for at least 7 days’ notice for most catering orders. For large events or custom requests, 2+ weeks is appreciated. Everything is baked to order in small batches with high-quality (local when available) ingredients.

💌 Have Questions or Special Requests?

We love collaborating on custom menus for events! Reach out through our contact page or email us at intheflourgarden@gmail.com. All inquiries are typically replied to within 48 business hours.